Matching paint colors across different brands can be a real challenge, especially when dealing with popular brands like Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams. While both brands offer a wide array of colors, their formulations and color systems can vary slightly, leading to subtle differences in final results. So, can you actually match Benjamin Moore colors with Sherwin Williams? The answer is not always a simple yes or no, but it’s definitely possible, with a little bit of understanding and the right approach.
Understanding the Color Matching Process
The core principle of color matching lies in the way manufacturers create and represent their colors. Both Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams use a specific color system based on the *Lab Color Space*, which assigns numerical values for lightness (L), red/green (a), and yellow/blue (b) to represent a particular color. This system allows manufacturers to accurately reproduce colors consistently.
However, the actual formulation and pigment concentration used to achieve those numerical values might differ slightly between brands. This is where the potential for color mismatch arises.
Matching Paint Colors: A Step-by-Step Guide
Here’s a detailed guide on how to approach matching Benjamin Moore colors to Sherwin Williams:
-
Identify the Benjamin Moore Color: Determine the exact Benjamin Moore color you wish to match, including its name, number, and any specific shade or tint variations.
-
Use a Color Matching Tool: Start with a reliable color matching tool, either online or through a paint store. Online tools can provide general suggestions, but in-store tools typically utilize spectrophotometers, which measure the color of a sample and offer more accurate matches.
-
Get a Color Sample: If you have a sample of the Benjamin Moore color, take it with you to a Sherwin Williams store. This allows their professionals to use the spectrophotometer to compare directly against their own color library.
-
Consider Lighting and Undertones: Be aware that colors can appear slightly different under varying lighting conditions. It’s always recommended to test samples on your walls in the intended space, during different times of day, to assess how the color behaves under different lighting.
-
Don’t Settle for a Perfect Match: It’s crucial to remember that achieving an absolute “perfect match” may be difficult due to the factors mentioned above. But aiming for a close match, a slight variation, or a color that complements the desired Benjamin Moore shade can be equally successful.
-
Don’t Hesitate to Ask for Expert Help: Both Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams have trained color consultants who can provide valuable guidance and support during the color matching process. They can assess the specific color you’re trying to match, suggest alternatives, and help you choose the closest Sherwin Williams match.
Key Considerations for a Successful Match
While the color matching process can be straightforward, it’s important to consider these key factors:
- Color Families: Matching colors within the same color family, such as blues, greens, or grays, tends to be easier than trying to match colors across vastly different families, like a bright orange to a muted purple.
- Undertones: Paying attention to undertones, such as warm or cool, can greatly impact the success of a color match. If the Benjamin Moore color has a significant undertone, it’s essential to consider it when choosing a Sherwin Williams equivalent.
- Color Depth: Matching colors with similar depth is crucial. A pale blue will likely not be a successful match for a deep navy, even if they have the same base color.
- Surface and Finish: The type of surface and the paint finish applied can influence how a color appears. For example, a color might appear different on a smooth, glossy surface compared to a textured, matte surface.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can I use an online tool to match Benjamin Moore colors to Sherwin Williams?
A: Online color matching tools can be a starting point but aren’t always foolproof. Their accuracy can vary depending on the specific tools used and the actual color being matched. For more reliable matches, consider in-store options with spectrophotometers.
Q: If I can’t get a perfect match, should I choose a slightly lighter or darker shade?
A: Whether to go slightly lighter or darker depends on the specific color and the desired effect. If you want to maintain the overall tone of the Benjamin Moore color, choosing a similar lightness level is recommended.
Q: What if I’m unsure about a color match?
A: Don’t hesitate to consult with a color consultant at a paint store. They can provide expert advice and help you choose the best Sherwin Williams match based on your individual needs and preferences.
Q: Can I match paint colors from other brands?
A: Yes, the process is similar for matching paint colors from any brand. Utilize color matching tools and consult with paint store professionals for the most accurate results.
Conclusion
While it’s not always possible to achieve a perfect color match between Benjamin Moore and Sherwin Williams, with a little bit of knowledge and guidance, it’s definitely possible to find a close match or a beautiful, complementary color. Remember, take your time, use reliable tools, and don’t hesitate to seek expert help to achieve the desired color for your project.
